This tutorial will walk you through the process of decorating sugar cookies with royal icing. I’ve found that the easiest way to decorate is using a Kuhn Rikon Cookie and Cupcake Decorating Set (available in The Shiksa Market.) These bottles are so much easier and less messy than using pastry bags; they’re also reusable, which makes them environmentally friendly. The accordion style of the smaller bottles help with creating details, they allow you to apply even pressure to create smooth lines with your icing. The set also includes four terrific decorating tips and a small spatula to help smooth out details. If you prefer using pastry bags, feel free—most of the tutorial will be helpful, whether or not you use the bottles. I just think the bottles are super nifty… they make decorating a lot easier.
The main thing to remember with icing cookies is texture. If the texture of the icing is correct, it will make decorating a lot easier. There are two main textures you will need to achieve—flood texture and detail texture. It will take some trial and error at first (which I learned after multiple attempts)—you will learn the proper texture with patience and practice. I’ve done my best to be detailed and make things as foolproof as possible, so hopefully you’ll get great results on the very first try! Once you master texture and a few other basics, you’ll be able to create gorgeous iced sugar cookies like these:
You will need at least one batch of Royal Icing to begin, as well as a batch of fully cooked sugar cookies. Links appear below.
- There are two steps to creating beautifully iced sugar cookies - flooding and detailing. Flooding describes the process used to create a smooth, beautiful "bed" of frosting on top of your cookies. This flat frosting surface creates a canvas, which you can then add detail frosting to. Both types of icing - flood and detail - have different textures. Each icing step begins with a batch of tinted (or white) Royal Icing - recipe can be found on TheShiksa.com
- First, create your flood icing. For this tutorial, I started with a vibrant blue royal icing to create a pretty Hanukkah canvas. Add water to your thick royal icing, a few drops at a time, using a spatula to stir the water in. The texture you are looking to achieve is somewhat similar to the texture of shampoo. Frosting can easily go from thick to fluid, so add water carefully and stir frequently till the right texture is achieved.
- To check if you have the right texture, use the "10 second rule." Drag a spatula through the frosting to make a line.
- Count how many seconds it takes for the surface of the frosting to become completely smooth again. It should take around 10 seconds... if it takes more time than that, your frosting needs more water added. If it takes less time, your frosting is too liquid-- stir in additional powdered sugar to thicken.
- Once your frosting is at the right texture, fill two decorating bottles (or pastry bags) with the frosting. For the bottle, I use a funnel to pour the frosting in, since the opening of the bottles is rather small.
- Pour frosting into the funnel. Agitate it with a thin knife, stirring and pushing the frosting through, till the bottle is full. This may take a few minutes.
- Once your two bottles are full of frosting, attach a tip to each one. I use a #1 round tip (small) for outlining and a #2 ribbon tip for flooding. In the Kuhn Rikon set, these tips are labeled #1 and #2.
- Place a small bowl with a damp paper towel on the side of your decorating area. You can place the bottles, tip side down, on top of this towel to keep the tips damp and clean-- royal icing is kind of like cement. Once it dries, it can plug up your tips and make decorating difficult. The damp paper towel will help keep this from happening.
- Keep unused icing in a bowl tightly covered with plastic wrap.
- Starting with the #1 tip bottle, squiggle a line on a piece of paper to make sure any air bubbles are pushed out. This will also give you an opportunity to get a "feel" for how quickly the frosting will flow from the bottle. Next, outline a cookie along the outer edge. This thin tip will create a liquid "dam" to keep the flood icing from dripping over the sides of the cookie.
- As soon as the outline is done, use the #2 tip bottle to fill the center of the cookie with icing. Imagine you are "coloring inside the lines" in a coloring book. Don't overdo it on the icing, a little goes a long way. If you add too much, the icing will leak over the outline you created and make a mess. Use the wide #2 tip to spread out the icing across the cookie and nudge it into detailed corners. Be patient, this process takes a gentle touch and takes some practice to get right... don't be hard on yourself, and take your time.
- Once the cookie is covered with icing, use a very small spatula or butter knife to smooth out any globs or uneven surfaces (the Kuhn Rikon set comes with a small plastic spatula). If your icing looks pretty even already, you may not need to do this.
- Use a toothpick to pop any small bubbles that have risen to the surface of the icing.
- Carefully grasp the outer edges of the cookie with two fingers and gently tap the cookie up and down to settle the icing. This will help to smooth out the surface even more.
- Let the icing dry for at least 3 hours, up to 24 hours. I let them dry overnight to make sure they're nice and firm before moving on to the detail icing stage.
- Once your flooded cookies are completely dry, you're ready to play! Detail icing is the most fun part of the cookie decorating process, in my opinion. Once you make a detail icing with the proper consistency, you'll have a blast "drawing" on top of the cookie and making all kinds of beautiful designs.
- Start with another batch of royal icing. For this tutorial, I used white, which made a lovely contrast to the blue flood icing. For the detail icing, you want your consistency to be thicker and more like glue than shampoo. If you use a 10-second rule for flood icing, I would say the detail icing will be more like a 25-second rule. It should be gloppy, not runny-- but not overly thick. Again, knowing the proper texture takes practice, so add water slowly and test the texture as you go.
- Fill a bottle with detail icing, using the same funnel method I outlined above. For detailing, I like using the Kuhn Rikon accordion bottles (included in the set). They make even, steady-handed application easier. Attach a #1 tip for thin detailed lines, or another tip of your choice to create pretty details (the star tip is nice for creating flower-like designs, while the #4 tip makes leaf-like designs. Feel free to get creative with your tips!
- Use the detail frosting bottle to decorate, as you would with a paint brush and thick paint. Press the #1 tip gently to the surface, squeeze, and lift straight up to create dots.
- To create straight lines, press your tip to the surface and squeeze to create a starting point. Immediately lift the tip, keeping your eye on the end point where you want your line to end. Keep your handy steady and pressure even as you pull towards the end point, lifting and then lowering when your line is finished.
- The lifting action will help you to control the straightness of the line. Again, it will take some practice to get a feel for the icing... have patience and don't be too hard on yourself!
- Once your lines have been added, grasp the cookie with two fingers and gently tap to smooth out the icing lines. If you see any small bubbles, pop them with a toothpick as you go. Small imperfections can usually be fixed with a toothpick, too, as long as you fix them within a minute or two of applying the icing. Once it starts to dry, it becomes more difficult to "clean up."
- While the detail frosting is wet, you can also add small detail effects, like candied beads and sprinkles. The frosting will act as a glue to hold the details in place.
- When you're done decorating, wait at least 3 hours up to overnight to dry. The longer the frosting dries, the more stable it becomes.
- Here are some decorating ideas for Hanukkah cookies. Of course, you can use this decorating process for any holiday, or just because! Let loose your inner artist and get creative. It's fun, and I find it strangely relaxing... almost like a meditation. The resulting cookies are like little pieces of art, almost too beautiful to eat! They make great gifts.